Sometimes, a jersey isn’t just a jersey—it’s a conversation starter, a piece of hockey lore, and maybe a little polarizing. Enter the Edmonton Oilers’ “McFarlane” third jersey. Designed by Todd McFarlane, the Canadian comic book creator behind Spawn, this jersey looked more like something you’d wear to fight intergalactic crime than skate in Alberta. But hey, hockey fans love a good plot twist.

This particular specimen? Worn by Mike York during the 2003-04 season. York, the Michigan State standout turned NHL journeyman, was part of six different NHL squads over his career. During his stint with the Oilers, he suited up in this jersey—a second set, third alternate, MeiGray-certified piece of Oilers history. It’s got all the hallmarks you’d want in a game-worn beauty: puck marks on the lower front, a stick slash across the crest, board burns on the elbow, and just enough grime to tell its story.

Oh, and let’s not forget the 25th Anniversary patch—because nothing says “this jersey means business” quite like a commemorative crest. The tri-layer tackle twill numbering, textured alternate crest, and navy-silver-white color scheme make it clear: this isn’t your standard Oilers sweater. Love it or hate it, the “McFarlane jersey” made a statement.

And while its initial reception was mixed—some fans embraced the bold departure from the Oilers’ classic look, others begged for a swift return to tradition—there’s no denying its impact. Decades later, it remains a fan favorite, with whispers of its potential comeback stirring nostalgia.

I managed to snag this one from the Classic Auctions Fall 2024 event, a rare find and even rarer with the 25th Anniversary patch intact. These don’t pop up often, so it was one of those “justified splurge” moments every collector knows